Top Iran Official’s Son Has Hand Amputated After Abandoning Islam to Follow Jesus || Testimony

EXCLUSIVE INVESTIGATION

The Boy From Brooklyn Who Vanished — And the Underground Faith Movement Quietly Spreading Across America

NEW YORK CITY — On a rainy November evening in lower Manhattan, a one-handed man stepped quietly onto a small church stage above a bakery near Canal Street and introduced himself to a room full of strangers.

“My name is Joseph Carter,” he said softly. “And five years ago, my family tried to erase me.”

The room fell silent.

There were no television cameras. No politicians. No flashing lights. Only folding chairs, paper coffee cups, and about forty people gathered in a rented second-floor room hidden above an old Chinese bakery where worship music played quietly through a cracked speaker.

Some in attendance were immigrants. Some were former gang members. Some were recovering addicts. Others were college students from New York University and Columbia curious about stories they had heard spreading online.

But everyone in the room was listening.

Joseph Carter’s story is one that sounds almost impossible in modern America — a story involving religious extremism, family violence, underground prayer groups, secret networks operating between New York, Ohio, and Los Angeles, and a journey that transformed a privileged American teenager into one of the most controversial faith voices quietly emerging in underground Christian communities.

For months, this newspaper investigated Carter’s claims, interviewing friends, former classmates, pastors, police officials, medical workers, and religious experts across four states.

What emerged was not merely the story of one man.

It was the story of a growing crisis unfolding beneath the surface of American life.

A Childhood Built on Fear

Joseph Carter was not born Joseph Carter.

According to school records and interviews with multiple sources who requested anonymity due to safety concerns, he was born Michael Reed in January 1997 in Brooklyn, New York.

His father, Reverend Nathaniel Reed, was a nationally recognized religious leader known for fiery sermons condemning secular America, modern culture, and what he called “moral collapse.”

By the early 2000s, Nathaniel Reed had built a powerful following stretching from New York to Ohio and parts of the South.

Former members describe his ministry as intensely authoritarian.

“He controlled everything,” said one former church member now living in Chicago. “What people wore. What music they listened to. Who they dated. Even how children were punished.”

The Reed family lived in a large brownstone in Brooklyn Heights only a few miles from downtown Manhattan, yet former neighbors say the atmosphere inside the home felt isolated from the modern world.

“There were curtains always closed,” one neighbor recalled. “The children were polite, but they looked scared all the time.”

Michael was the youngest of four children.

Friends from his early years describe him as unusually sensitive.

“He loved animals,” said a former elementary school classmate now working as a teacher in Queens. “He cried when another kid stepped on a bird in the playground. That kind of thing stayed with him.”

Inside the Reed household, however, softness was treated as weakness.

Former church materials reviewed during this investigation show strict teachings emphasizing obedience, discipline, and punishment.

Children were expected to memorize scripture daily. Public mistakes often resulted in humiliation or corporal punishment.

“He believed fear created purity,” said a former assistant pastor from Ohio. “That was his philosophy.”

By age seven, Michael was already preaching short sermons to youth groups.

By ten, he was attending advanced Bible training programs run by his father’s ministry.

By thirteen, according to former classmates, he had become increasingly withdrawn.

“He looked exhausted,” one recalled. “Like he carried pressure no kid should carry.”

Yet publicly, the Reed family appeared untouchable.

Nathaniel Reed preached at megachurch conferences from Cleveland to Dallas. His radio broadcasts reached thousands weekly. Videos of his sermons circulated online among conservative religious communities.

Inside church circles, the Reed name carried enormous influence.

No one imagined the pastor’s own son was beginning to question everything.

The Questions That Changed Everything

The turning point appears to have begun during Michael’s late teenage years.

In 2014, he relocated temporarily to Columbus, Ohio, to study under a partner ministry connected to his father’s organization.

Former students who attended the training center described an environment of constant pressure.

“We were told the world outside was evil,” one former attendee said. “Questioning leadership was treated like rebellion against God.”

But Columbus also exposed Michael to a world beyond the rigid environment of his upbringing.

For the first time, he encountered people from different religions, political views, and social backgrounds.

According to interviews with multiple sources, the most significant meeting occurred inside a small independent bookstore near Ohio State University.

That is where Michael met Daniel Alvarez.

Alvarez, now 34 and living in Los Angeles, agreed to speak on record for this article.

“I remember him immediately,” Alvarez said during a video interview. “He looked terrified all the time. Even when he smiled.”

At the time, Alvarez was working part-time while studying graphic design.

“He came in wearing conservative clothes, carrying theology books,” Alvarez recalled. “At first, he barely talked.”

Over time, short conversations developed.

“We started talking about grace,” Alvarez said.

Grace.

The word would later appear repeatedly throughout Carter’s journals.

According to Alvarez, Michael struggled deeply with the idea that love could exist without fear.

“He told me everything in his life felt earned,” Alvarez said. “Approval. Acceptance. God’s love. Even family.”

Alvarez eventually gave him a small pocket New Testament.

That decision would ignite a chain reaction nobody involved fully understood at the time.

The Secret Transformation

Over the following months, Michael began privately reading the Gospels.

Friends from the training center noticed changes.

“He stopped yelling during debates,” one student remembered. “He became quieter. Kinder.”

Others noticed him skipping mandatory prayer meetings.

According to journal entries reviewed during this investigation, Michael became increasingly disturbed by what he described as “a faith built on terror instead of love.”

One handwritten page reads:

“What if God is not trying to crush people? What if He is trying to heal them?”

The journals, now kept securely by Carter, contain hundreds of pages documenting his psychological unraveling.

Nightmares. Panic attacks. Fear of eternal damnation.

But also hope.

One recurring image appears again and again.

A man dressed in white standing beside water.

“I don’t know who he is,” one early entry says. “But I feel safe when he looks at me.”

By late 2014, Michael had secretly begun attending small Bible gatherings hosted in apartments around Columbus.

Participants included former addicts, college students, undocumented immigrants, and disillusioned former church members.

“It was the first time he saw faith without intimidation,” said Pastor Elias Moreno, who led several gatherings. “Nobody was screaming. Nobody was threatening hell every five minutes. That shocked him.”

In early January 2015, according to Carter, he privately committed his life to Christianity.

He never imagined how violently his family would react.

The Night Everything Exploded

What happened next remains disputed.

Police records from Brooklyn confirm officers responded to a domestic disturbance at the Reed residence on January 19, 2015.

No arrests were made.

Hospital records reviewed by this newspaper confirm a nineteen-year-old male later appeared at a private emergency clinic in Queens with catastrophic injuries to his left hand.

The details connecting those two events remain heavily contested.

Joseph Carter insists his father attacked him after discovering hidden Christian materials in his bedroom.

Members of the Reed family have repeatedly denied the allegation.

Nathaniel Reed, now 68 and still active in ministry work in Ohio, refused multiple interview requests.

Through an attorney, the family released a brief statement:

“The allegations made by Mr. Carter are false, defamatory, and motivated by financial and ideological interests. The Reed family categorically denies involvement in any criminal conduct.”

Yet multiple independent witnesses confirmed intense conflict occurred inside the home.

One former family acquaintance recalled receiving frantic late-night phone calls from Michael’s older sister.

“She said things had gotten out of control,” the source said.

Another witness described hearing shouting from inside the residence.

“He was screaming that Michael had betrayed God,” the witness claimed.

What happened afterward remains partially obscured.

Carter says he was beaten severely and attacked with a blade inside the family garage after refusing to renounce Christianity.

He claims he lost his left hand during the assault.

Medical specialists consulted for this investigation reviewed injury descriptions anonymously.

Several stated the wounds appeared “consistent with deliberate traumatic amputation.”

No criminal charges were ever filed.

By dawn, Michael Reed had vanished.

His family publicly claimed he was receiving psychiatric treatment out of state.

Privately, according to multiple former ministry members, rumors spread that he had become “possessed” or “radicalized.”

In reality, Carter says, he was hiding in Queens under the care of a small underground network of Christians.

Underground America

Most Americans associate underground churches with authoritarian countries overseas.

But investigators and religious freedom advocates say loosely organized underground faith networks increasingly exist within the United States as well.

Not because Christianity itself is banned — but because certain converts fear retaliation from families, gangs, extremist groups, or tightly controlled religious communities.

“These networks are real,” said Dr. Amanda Holbrook, a sociologist specializing in religious trauma at the University of Southern California. “They operate quietly to relocate vulnerable individuals facing threats after leaving high-control environments.”

Carter spent nearly a year moving between safe houses in Queens, Newark, Cleveland, and eventually Los Angeles.

Former volunteers who assisted him describe a man physically shattered but emotionally transformed.

“He should have been consumed with rage,” said Rachel Kim, a nurse from New Jersey who treated him during recovery. “Instead, he kept talking about forgiveness.”

During this period, Carter adopted the name Joseph.

“It represented survival,” he later explained during a church testimony in Los Angeles. “Someone betrayed by his own family but not abandoned by God.”

He also underwent extensive rehabilitation.

Learning basic tasks again — dressing himself, writing, cooking — became daily battles.

Therapists who worked with trauma survivors say such injuries often trigger devastating psychological collapse.

Yet several people close to Carter describe an opposite trajectory.

“He became calmer after everything happened,” Alvarez said. “That sounds insane, but it’s true.”

Friends say he spent hours reading scripture, journaling, and speaking with other survivors of religious abuse.

One recurring theme emerged constantly:

Freedom.

Los Angeles and the Hidden Gatherings

By 2016, Carter had relocated to Los Angeles under a confidential support program.

There, according to church leaders and local volunteers, he began quietly sharing his story among small house churches operating across Southern California.

Some gatherings took place in apartments near Koreatown.

Others met inside garages, coffee shops, or rented community halls.

The attendees varied dramatically.

Former gang members from East LA sat beside Iranian immigrants, recovering addicts, undocumented workers, college students, and ex-members of extremist religious movements.

“People think underground faith only exists overseas,” said Pastor Miguel Herrera, who hosted several meetings. “But America has its own hidden wounded population.”

Carter rarely preached traditionally.

“He wasn’t polished,” Herrera said. “He spoke like someone still healing.”

That authenticity resonated.

Video clips from private gatherings began circulating online.

In one recording obtained during this investigation, Carter rolls up his sleeve, revealing the scarred remains of his left arm.

“They took my hand,” he says quietly. “But fear had already taken far more from me before that.”

The room remains silent for nearly twenty seconds afterward.

Those who attended the meetings say Carter became especially influential among young Americans disillusioned by performative religion.

“He talked about God like someone who survived a war,” one attendee from Santa Monica said.

Yet visibility brought danger.

In 2017, Carter reported receiving anonymous threats online.

Several accused him of fabricating his story.

Others called him a traitor to Christianity for criticizing authoritarian church culture.

Some came from former members of his father’s ministry.

According to internal emails reviewed by this newspaper, church leaders warned followers against consuming “deceptive narratives designed to weaken biblical authority.”

Carter continued speaking anyway.

America’s Growing Religious Trauma Crisis

Experts say Carter’s story reflects broader national trends.

Across the United States, increasing numbers of former members of high-control religious communities are speaking publicly about abuse, coercion, and psychological manipulation.

Organizations supporting survivors report surging demand.

“People assume religious trauma only affects fringe cults,” said Dr. Holbrook. “That’s not accurate anymore.”

Former evangelicals, ex-Mormons, ultra-fundamentalist Christians, and survivors from multiple faith backgrounds increasingly describe similar patterns:

Fear-based teaching.

Isolation.

Punishment.

Control.

Conditional love.

For some, leaving such environments means losing entire families.

Others face stalking, threats, or social exile.

Carter’s case stands out because of its extreme violence.

But advocates say the emotional patterns surrounding it are tragically common.

“Many survivors describe feeling invisible their entire childhood,” said trauma counselor Denise Warren from Cleveland. “Then someone finally treats them with compassion and everything changes.”

That exact language appears repeatedly throughout Carter’s interviews.

“I spent years terrified of God,” he said during a 2022 gathering in Manhattan. “Then I encountered love instead of fear.”

The Letter From Ohio

In late 2018, Carter received a handwritten letter from his older sister, Naomi.

The letter, portions of which were shared with this newspaper, marked the first contact from his family since his disappearance.

“I don’t know what I believe anymore,” she wrote. “But I miss my brother.”

According to Carter, the letter shattered years of emotional numbness.

“She was the only person who was gentle with me growing up,” he said.

The siblings eventually reestablished limited contact through encrypted messaging.

Naomi declined an interview request but confirmed via email that communication resumed.

“I love my brother,” she wrote. “That is all I wish to say publicly.”

The relationship with his father remains severed.

Several sources close to the Reed ministry claim Nathaniel Reed still refuses to acknowledge Joseph publicly.

Yet Carter insists he no longer feels hatred.

“That took years,” he admitted during an interview in New York earlier this spring. “Forgiveness is not pretending something didn’t happen. It’s refusing to let evil become your identity.”

The New York Mission

Today, Joseph Carter lives quietly in Queens.

At thirty-one years old, he works with a nonprofit organization assisting survivors of religious trauma and newly displaced immigrants.

Every week, he travels between New York, Philadelphia, and Newark mentoring vulnerable young adults.

Some are homeless.

Some escaped violent households.

Some simply feel spiritually lost.

The meetings themselves appear remarkably ordinary.

Cheap coffee.

Plastic chairs.

Folding tables covered in pizza boxes.

But attendees describe profound emotional impact.

“He listens,” said Marcus Hill, a former drug addict from the Bronx. “Most religious people talk at you. Joseph listens.”

On Sunday afternoons, small gatherings continue above the bakery near Canal Street.

Songs are sung softly in English and Spanish.

Prayers are whispered.

People cry openly.

Nobody shouts.

Nobody threatens hell.

Nobody demands perfection.

For many attending, that alone feels revolutionary.

“He creates safety,” said volunteer coordinator Elena Ramirez. “That’s rare these days.”

Carter himself remains uncomfortable with attention.

During interviews, he repeatedly redirected focus away from himself.

“I’m not special,” he insisted. “There are thousands of people carrying hidden wounds.”

Still, his story continues spreading.

Clips from testimonies delivered in New York and Los Angeles have accumulated millions of views across social media platforms.

Supporters describe him as a voice for survivors.

Critics accuse him of exaggeration and emotional manipulation.

Carter says neither label matters much anymore.

“I already lost everything once,” he said quietly. “Public opinion doesn’t scare me.”

A Country Searching For Meaning

Why has Joseph Carter’s story resonated so powerfully?

Sociologists suggest the answer may lie in America’s growing spiritual exhaustion.

Trust in institutions — including religious institutions — continues declining nationwide.

Young Americans increasingly report feelings of loneliness, anxiety, and disillusionment.

At the same time, social media has amplified deeply emotional stories of trauma and recovery.

Carter’s journey sits directly at that intersection.

Pain.

Faith.

Identity.

Survival.

Redemption.

“He represents a kind of spiritual refugee,” Dr. Holbrook explained. “Someone fleeing fear-based systems in search of authentic connection.”

Whether one agrees with his theology or not, the emotional force of the story is difficult to ignore.

Even critics acknowledge the sincerity of his convictions.

“He genuinely believes what he’s saying,” one former family associate admitted. “That’s what makes this complicated.”

Meanwhile, underground support communities across the country continue expanding.

Private gatherings now exist in New York, Chicago, Phoenix, Seattle, Atlanta, and Los Angeles.

Some focus specifically on survivors of spiritual abuse.

Others simply provide spaces where people can ask difficult questions without fear.

Carter frequently travels between them.

“He shows up for people,” said Pastor Herrera from Los Angeles. “That’s why they trust him.”

The River At Night

Late last month, this reporter met Joseph Carter beside the East River after one of the Manhattan gatherings.

The city glowed behind him.

Cars rushed across the Williamsburg Bridge.

Cold wind swept along the water.

Carter wore a dark jacket and carried a worn leather Bible tucked beneath one arm.

When asked whether he regretted the path that destroyed his relationship with his family, he remained silent for a long moment.

Finally, he shook his head.

“I regret the pain,” he said. “I regret what fear did to all of us.”

Then he looked down at the empty sleeve pinned neatly against his coat.

“But losing this hand wasn’t the worst thing that happened to me.”

What was?

He stared out at the river before answering.

“Living my entire childhood believing love had to be earned.”

The wind carried the sound of distant sirens through the city.

Nearby, ferries crossed slowly through black water reflecting Manhattan’s lights.

Carter smiled faintly.

“For years,” he said, “I thought God wanted perfection.”

Then he paused.

“Now I think He wanted honesty.”

As midnight approached, people continued leaving the church gathering above the bakery one by one.

Some hugged each other before disappearing into the subway.

Others lingered on the sidewalk talking quietly beneath flickering neon signs.

Inside, volunteers folded chairs and stacked paper cups into trash bags.

The room looked ordinary again.

Yet for those gathered there, the evening carried the feeling of something larger unfolding quietly beneath the surface of American life.

Not a movement built on power.

Not on celebrity.

Not on fear.

But on wounded people searching for grace in a country increasingly uncertain where grace can still be found.

And at the center of that movement stands a soft-spoken man from Brooklyn with one hand, a scarred past, and a story America cannot quite decide whether to fear, question, or believe.

But regardless of what people conclude, one fact remains undeniable:

Joseph Carter survived.

And in surviving, he became something his younger self never imagined possible.

Free.